The novel "Jane Eyre" is the great work of all time. It's such a beautiful love story. Jane Eyre is one. However, she is different for each person.
The director of the adaptation of the novel in 1934 decided that Jane Eyre was a blonde.
![]() |
Virginia Bruce (Jane Eyre) and Colin Clive (Mr. Rochester),1934 |
The new version of film appeared in 1944. The main role was played by Joana Fontaine. This film wasn't
very long, a lot of details were missed.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/dd0df/dd0df8c214d8dd00f6fd5d7e1bdcd3752e919f37" alt="eir4fo6.jpg"
very long, a lot of details were missed.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/dd0df/dd0df8c214d8dd00f6fd5d7e1bdcd3752e919f37" alt="eir4fo6.jpg"
The film with Susannah York which was shown in 1970 was undramatic.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ba341/ba3413d77eb16ef5cdba40c536a6dfd7a73c2c63" alt="Сюзанна Йорк Сюзанна Йорк"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ba341/ba3413d77eb16ef5cdba40c536a6dfd7a73c2c63" alt="Сюзанна Йорк Сюзанна Йорк"
Then in 1973 soap opera "Jane Eyre" was realesed. There were 5 series. This adaptation is one of the best.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/90ce5/90ce5f38d5e734a2d7fae26e5036154654a0c572" alt="Сорча Кьюсак Сорча Кьюсак"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/90ce5/90ce5f38d5e734a2d7fae26e5036154654a0c572" alt="Сорча Кьюсак Сорча Кьюсак"
Another soap opera appeared in 1983.The main roles were played by Timothy Dalton and Zelah Clarke.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ce012/ce01230e4737a1bdf030ea77ca736c2158a417d4" alt=""
The film appeared in 1996 was marked by the emotional game by Charlotte Gainsbourg and William Hurt.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/51cb2/51cb2b30fe569fc5399f58b1aaf8e2dc4c2e0881" alt=""
Next year a new film adaptation appeared. The film had not received special praise. Mr. Rochester seemed very aggressive.
There was a new soap opera with Ruth Wilson in the main role. The soap opera did not make much impression on the audience.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/51cb2/51cb2b30fe569fc5399f58b1aaf8e2dc4c2e0881" alt=""
Next year a new film adaptation appeared. The film had not received special praise. Mr. Rochester seemed very aggressive.
![]() |
Samantha Morton and Ciaran Hinds, 1997 |
There was a new soap opera with Ruth Wilson in the main role. The soap opera did not make much impression on the audience.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1dce5/1dce5a26bf2682474d4ba71e98062b4fee1a8eca" alt=""
Over a year ago came the modern version of "Jane Eyre" with Mia Wasikowska.
Unfortunately, I saw only one film. It was the film of the last year. I can't compare the films to each other but try to compare the book and the film. In my opinion, the book is definitely better. And it's not just about my book. I have not seen a screen version that was able to outmatch the book. And it's not because the filmmakers do not know how to make movies. The problem is that when we watch a movie we do not think. We do not think about heroes and their images:directors and actors have already done everything for us. In the book, it's different. We should represent faces, voices and movements of the protagonists. We imagine a space where all the events take place. The reader is the boss there. It's much more interesting,isn"t it? Let's read the books!
I like your comparison of all the versions released. You did good research but your analysis could be improved.
ОтветитьУдалить